Finance · · 5 min read
What a quality of earnings review is, and when you need one
A quality of earnings review tests whether a company's profit is real and repeatable. What it covers, how it differs from an audit and what to prepare.
In an acquisition, the price is usually a multiple of earnings. That makes the earnings number the most important figure in the deal, and a quality of earnings review, or QoE, is how buyers test it.
What it answers
A QoE asks whether the business's profit is accurate, sustainable and representative of what a new owner will actually earn. It typically covers:
- Normalized EBITDA: adjusting reported earnings for one-time items, owner compensation and accounting choices.
- Revenue quality: customer concentration, recurring versus one-off revenue, churn and pricing trends.
- Net working capital: what normal levels look like, which feeds the working capital peg in the purchase agreement.
- Proof of cash: reconciling reported revenue to actual bank deposits.
- Debt-like items: obligations that should reduce the price, such as deferred revenue, unpaid bonuses or overdue taxes.
How it differs from an audit
An audit asks whether financial statements follow accounting rules. A QoE asks whether the earnings are a sound basis for a price. A business can have a clean audit and still have earnings that will not survive a change of ownership, for example if the founder brings in most of the sales.
Buy-side and sell-side
Buyers commission a QoE to check the numbers before they commit. Sellers increasingly commission their own before going to market, so surprises come out early and on their terms, rather than in the middle of negotiations.
What to prepare
- Three years of monthly financial statements and the general ledger.
- Bank statements for the same period.
- Customer-level revenue data.
- Payroll records and owner compensation details.
- Support for every proposed add-back.
Before you pay for one
A full QoE from an accounting firm is a significant expense. A first-pass review of normalized earnings and revenue quality helps you decide whether a deal is worth that spend.
Ineffable's M&A Analyst helps your team do that first pass and prepare an investment committee memo, with your CFO or deal lead signing off.