People · · 6 min read
How to read a health insurance renewal
Your group health renewal arrived with a big increase. Here is what drives the number, what is negotiable and how to compare your options.
Group health renewals often arrive a few months before the plan year, sometimes with an increase that wipes out the budget. Before accepting it or switching carriers, it helps to understand what is behind the number.
What drives a renewal
- Medical trend: the general rise in healthcare costs and utilization, which applies to almost every group.
- Demographics: changes in the age and family mix of your enrolled employees.
- Claims experience: how much your group actually used. Its weight depends on your size and funding model.
- Plan changes and regulatory fees.
Under the ACA, small groups in most states are rated using adjusted community rating, so their own claims history matters less. Larger groups are usually experience rated, and a few high-cost claims can move the renewal significantly.
Questions to ask your broker or carrier
- How much of the increase is trend, demographics and claims?
- Were there large individual claims, and are they likely to continue?
- What would the renewal be with different plan designs?
- Has the plan been marketed to other carriers?
- Would level funding or self-funding with stop-loss suit our size?
Levers you can pull
- Plan design: deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, copays and coinsurance.
- A high-deductible plan with an HSA, ideally with an employer contribution.
- Offering two plans so employees can choose.
- Contribution strategy: how much the company pays for employees versus dependants.
- Network choices: narrower networks can lower premiums.
- Funding model: level-funded and self-funded plans can return savings in good years, but carry more risk.
Compare options properly
For each option, model the cost to the company and the cost to employees per paycheck at each coverage tier. A plan that saves the company money but shifts large costs to employees with families may hurt retention more than it helps the budget.
Check compliance
If you have 50 or more full-time equivalent employees, the ACA employer mandate requires affordable coverage that meets minimum value. Changing contributions can affect affordability. Plan documents, summary plan descriptions and, for larger plans, Form 5500 filings also need to stay current. In Canada, extended health and dental plans sit on top of provincial coverage and have their own rules for taxable benefits.
Tell employees early and clearly
Explain what changed, what it costs per paycheck and how to choose, in plain language, well before open enrollment.
Ineffable's Benefits Administrator helps your team break down a renewal, compare options and draft the employee guide for your broker or HR lead to review.